Paperback Mistletoe and Mayhem – Heywood Herbalist Cozy Mystery Book 4 | Carly Winter
Paperback Mistletoe and Mayhem – Heywood Herbalist Cozy Mystery Book 4 | Carly Winter
4.77 / 5.0
(39) 39 total reviews
Couldn't load pickup availability
’Tis the season for murder in Heywood — and Sam Jones is the only one who can save Christmas.
When Mrs. Claus is found murdered days before the Annual Heywood Christmas Festival, Sheriff Mallory Richards cancels the beloved event. As the flu takes out the whole sheriff’s department—except for Deputy Jordan Branson—he begs Sam to help him find the killer.
She and Annabelle set out to catch the murderer but land themselves in a tangled web of deception and danger. Will they be able to find the killer and save the Christmas Festival, or will Sam and Annabelle get too close to the truth and end up silenced?
📖 Prefer an ebook? → Ebook
🎧 Love audiobooks? → Audiobook
📚 Browse all books → Heywood Herbalist series page
📖 Read the First Chapter
Copyright 2026 Carly Winter
All Rights Reserved
Christmas. My favorite time of the year. I loved everything about the holiday: the decorations, the food, and… the Christmas songs were wonderful—until they weren’t.
You know that song, “Last Christmas I Gave You My Heart,” by Wham!? The beautiful pop-like ballad oozing so much emotion, tears may spring to your eyes while listening to it?
Yes, it’s one of my favorites. Well, it was until my friend and employee, Annabelle, decided to play it on loop.
“Can we listen to something else?” I asked after the fourth time of listening to her belt out the song off tune.
“Don’t be such a Scrooge,” she said. “Who doesn’t love this song?”
I knew quite a few people who couldn’t stand the tune, but I’d let that one slide. “There are a million other Christmas songs so let’s go for some variety, okay?”
She ran a hand over her crimped blonde hair as I returned to my task of tying bows on the gift baskets of products made from my store, Sage Advice. With Christmas only a week away, we’d been working overtime to fulfill the online orders, as well as those from the locals of Heywood, Arizona, where we lived. But these particular baskets were for the Christmas festival being held in a few short days.
Finally, Bing Crosby’s smooth voice filled the air singing “White Christmas.” I loved George Michael, but not enough to listen to his song on repeat. Annabelle, however, had a dedication to the 80s I’d never seen in anyone before… and it wasn’t just the music. Her hair, the way she dressed, her vintage t-shirts… Sometimes, I wondered if it could be a little unhealthy and she should leave the past where it was.
“Did you ever meet him?” she asked.
“Who? Bing Crosby? I’m not that old, Annabelle.” I shook my head and rolled my eyes.
“No, silly! George Michael! Did you ever meet him?”
As a former Hollywood starlet, I’d had the opportunity to meet a lot of famous people. “Yes,” I said.
She squealed and clapped her hands together. Although she was in her fifties, she sometimes acted childish, which I appreciated because it made me feel younger as well. “Tell me everything! Was he as sweet as he seemed in interviews?”
I nodded and set down my scissors. “I’d been invited to a dinner party at a producer’s house. There were about twenty of us. He was very kind and soft-spoken. Quite funny. I really enjoyed that evening.”
“Oh, my gosh,” Annabelle said. “I envy your former life so much!”
Smiling, I returned to my task. My former life had been great in some respects, like meeting George Michael, having rabid fans for my soap opera, As The Years Turn, and being quite wealthy. But there were downsides as well. Hollywood could be a cruel place and I’d suffered greatly at its hands when my husband had been murdered. All in all, I preferred my anonymous life in Heywood, running my herbal store.
“We just need to finish the bows on these, then they’re ready to go,” I said. “Next, we better make some more sage soap. Those seem to be flying off the shelves.”
“Agreed,” Annabelle said. “We should also put out more Elderberry tinctures. Everyone’s trying to stay healthy for Christmas.”
With the flu going around Heywood, people were getting sick faster than I could keep track.
“We should also get set up at the Christmas Festival,” Annabelle said. “Hopefully they gave us a prime table to show our gift baskets. We have to be there by six.”
I hadn’t been sure about participating in the festival, but Annabelle had convinced me it would be a great idea for the business. I glanced at the clock. Gosh. Where had the day gone? It was just after five, and although I’d been working since seven this morning, I’d been so busy, time had flown by. I’d even skipped lunch. “You’re right. We better get moving.”
After loading the gift baskets in the back of Annabelle’s car, saying goodbye to my cat, Catnip, and locking up the store, we drove a few blocks to the community center. Normally, I would’ve walked the short distance, but we’d received even more snow and the roads were slippery.
“There’s supposed to be a dress rehearsal tonight,” Annabelle said. “The choir is going to work out their placement on the stage, Santa and Mrs. Claus are going to practice their entrance, and the cheer team from the high school will also be going through their performance. I love watching it all come together before the big night.”
The big night, as she called it, consisted of the whole town gathering to watch the show, kids getting their pictures taken with Santa and Mrs. Claus, a Christmas pie and cookie bakeoff, and singing carols. Not to mention people being able to complete their last-minute shopping from local vendors. Annabelle had told me stories of fists flying when one baker felt slighted in the judging portion of the night. I couldn’t imagine getting upset over someone liking another person’s cookies more than mine, but I also couldn’t bake worth a darn.
As we drove, I stared out the passenger window at the transformation of Heywood. Lights decorated every store. Most had wreaths hanging from their doors and Christmas offerings showcased in their display windows. Small Christmas flags and garland decorations hung from the streetlights while Christmas music played from speakers around town I hadn’t even known existed. The place looked like something out of a Hallmark Christmas movie, and I was still in awe of its beauty. It had all begun the day after Thanksgiving and it seemed like all the merchants were working in coordination to get it done a few days later.
How different this holiday was from my Hollywood years.
First, I never decorated. My housekeeper and I came up with a theme sometime around Halloween, and then she contacted a professional decorator. I literally arrived home from work one evening and found my house transformed into a wonderland of beautiful, sparkly baubles. Every year, my husband, Gerald, and I held a catered Christmas party. All our so-called friends would come to the outdoor gathering where our backyard was also transformed into a winter wonderland, even though we lived in Los Angeles. Ice sculptures and piles of fake snow were placed strategically around our yard while Santa and a live reindeer or two were available for pictures. A first-class buffet was tended to by servers in bowties, bringing around trays of champagne from the open bar.
This Christmas, I was headed to the Heywood Community Center to set out my handmade gift baskets with the hope people would buy them. And I was worried about how I would afford Christmas gifts for Annabelle and my friend—who might have been my boyfriend if I dated—Deputy Jordan Branson, as well as my other friend, Gina, the dog rescuer, ghost writer, and owner of a local nail salon.
Once we arrived at the Community Center, I exited the car and glanced upward as snow began to fall once again, the flakes hitting my cheeks.
“I wonder where everyone is?” Annabelle asked, opening the trunk to her car. “I thought more store owners would be here to set up their tables.”
Glancing around the parking lot, I realized we were the only ones there, but the footprints in the snow indicated some people had been in and out. “Looks like they were here earlier,” I said, pointing at the ground.
I grabbed as many baskets as I could carry and carefully treaded through the calf-high snow. Unfortunately, the town snowplow had some mechanical issues and hadn’t been able to clear the roads and parking lots in two days. As the gentle flakes continued their beautiful descent, cold silence engulfed us. A chill ran down my spine and I felt as if we were the only two people left in Heywood… or in the middle of a horror movie.
Lights blazed from the building ahead, and when we got closer, I heard “Silent Night” playing from within. Hopefully, setup would be quick and easy as I was longing to curl up on my couch with Catnip and have a glass of wine or two. My shoulders slumped with exhaustion, and I realized the holidays were a lot of work when I couldn’t pass the duties to someone else.
Annabelle balanced her baskets on her leg and pulled open the door. Once inside, we stamped our boots on the large red welcome rug to remove the snow.
“The wood floor gets a little slick when it’s wet, so watch your step,” Annabelle said.
Great. Just what I needed—another fall. I’d already had three since the snow started about two months ago, and my distaste for winter grew with each day. I loved looking at the snow, I just didn’t like trying to live my life in it.
We walked through the foyer, hung a right, and headed for the big gymnasium. A strange odor of pine needles, cinnamon, and sweaty shoes engulfed us the closer we got, causing me to grimace. It was my understanding that the boys’ basketball teams often practiced here, which explained the sweaty shoe smell.
When we entered the huge space, I gasped, forgetting the odor. Never would I have imagined a gym could look so pretty.
A large Christmas tree twinkled in the middle of the basketball court while thousands of tiny lights had been strung across the ceiling and along the walls, all glittering and giving off enough illumination the harsh, fluorescent lights weren’t necessary. In a corner sat two high-back red velvet chairs with silver legs and gold and silver intricacies woven into the fabric, placed on a red and green rug. “That’s for Santa and his wife,” Annabelle said, pointing at them. “Last year they had elves as well. I don’t know if they’ll do that this year, though.”
“Why’s that?”
“Well, Santa, like, has a bit of a drinking problem and him and one of the elves he’d been boozing with got into a fistfight.”
“Oh, my.”
“Yes. They were rolling on the floor with fists swinging, cursing at each other. It wasn’t one of Heywood’s finest moments.”
“Why don’t they get a new Santa?” I asked.
“Wait until you see him,” she said. “You couldn’t find a more perfect Santa. He’s been playing the role for fifteen years now and loves it. He plans for it all year long.”
Along the walls sat empty tables. I noted a few had been decorated with tablecloths and had goods arranged on them. “See? I told you we weren’t the first ones here,” I said, pointing at them.
“Apparently not,” Annabelle, replied. “Let’s find our table. Hopefully we’ve got a good one close to the door.”
We found our spot along with a couple fold-out metal chairs labeled Sage Advice, fourth in from the door, in between Jemisphere, the local jewelry shop, and Locked and Loaded, the gun store.
“This is great!” Annabelle said as we set down our baskets and purses, then I stripped out of my coat as a hot flash hit while Annabelle kept hers on.
“Who’s going to buy someone a gun for Christmas?” I asked, pointing at the Locked and Loaded table.
“Your California mentality is showing,” Annabelle muttered, rolling her eyes. “I love getting guns and gear to go with them for Christmas.”
Huh. Well, at least I knew what to put under the tree for her.
As Annabelle danced around to “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” coming through the gymnasium speakers, we set out our own tablecloth—green with red and silver trim bearing the store’s name—to cover the old, worn table.
Our gift baskets were tied with red or green bows, a sneaky idea we’d come up with while preparing them. A red bow meant one price, a green bow meant another. That way we’d know on sight how much to charge the customer. Genius, if you asked me.
We arranged the display, adding a few embellishments like the candy dish full of candy canes and a few bows we pinned on the front of the tablecloth surrounding the store’s name, as well as a string of small white lights to go around the table. We then placed our inventory underneath and stepped back to admire our work.
“That looks fantastic,” Annabelle said. Glancing around at the other tables, she leaned in and whispered, “Much better than the other ones that have been set up.”
I nodded in agreement. “Let’s go take a closer look.”
We walked around, stopping at Knit Wit’s table to check out her offerings. Since the physical store sat next to mine out on Comfort Road, I knew the owner, Mrs. Mason, well. She was offering knitted dolls and discounts on knitting classes.
“Gina’s going to try to adopt out some of her rescues,” I said, pointing at a sign that read Heywood Hounds, the name of Gina’s rescue business.
The next table took us to the other side of the gym where we found Too Hot To Handle, a hot sauce joint.
“I wonder how hot that Devil’s Juice is,” Annabelle said, pointing to the jar. “I imagine it would fry off your eyebrows.”
“Probably.” I turned to glance at the tree and a scream stuck in my throat as I grabbed Annabelle’s arm.
“What?” she asked.
I pointed at the tree, still unable to speak.
“Oh my gosh!” she yelled. We ran over to find a woman dressed in a Santa suit staring up at the ceiling with milky, dead eyes, a small pool of blood surrounding her head. Annabelle fell to her knees and felt for a pulse, but I already knew the answer.
She turned and looked up at me, tears brimming in her eyes. “Who in the world would kill Mrs. Claus?”

I love Sam and Annabelle and this book, the 4th in the series, did not disappoint! I love how much Annabelle loves Christmas and her eccentric personality. Unfortunately, the most wonderful time of the year is not holly and jolly. Time for Sam and Annabelle to join forces with Jordan (especially since the flu takes out the sheriff's department) and help him solve a murder.I listened to the audiobook and it was excellent and easy to follow along. This is the 4th of 6 books. While I am happy to have read it, I am sad knowing there are only 2 more left in the series.
I listened to the audible version of this very good story and fun series. I really enjoy the narrator's voice. The story is fast paced with great main characters and several quirky ones throughout the plot. The Christmas setting is well described and the Mrs. Claus murder mystery has a few twists keeping the story interesting. I look forward to reading the next in the series wondering what lies ahead for Sam. Each book in the series is a standalone however I am enjoying following all the main characters' journeys in each book.I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This fun Christmas Cozy mystery is a great new chapter in the Heywood Herbalist Cozy Mystery series. Daytime diva Samantha Rathbone has built a new life in smalltown Heywood Arizona. Only her best friend knows who Sam Jones really is. When Mrs. Clause is murdered it looks like the Heywood Christmas festival may need to be cancelled. The author has added a cute twist to the usual coy plot. Everyone but our cute deputy is down with the flu.Instead of being told not to investigate, Sam is asked to help. This book is a quick read and just as much fun as the earlier books. Since there is a recap at the beginning, it can be read a s a stand alone. Readers will want to know that the last chapter of these books are always a lead in to the next mystery.
I enjoyed this book so much , that I'm planning on reading the next one. The writing and story is absolutely stunning.Well written Cozy Mystery just the way I like it.
"Mistletoe and Mayhem" is the 4th "Heywood Herbalist Cozy Mysteries" by Carly Winter. They're all super quick reads but that doesn't deter from the story. I'm glad that despite their length there is some "time" between dead bodies. Other cozy mysteries that are short seem to have things happening within days of the previous book. That is not the case with these. I appreciate that. I also like that things are actually progressing with Sam's various relationships.